Store Score Blog

Are You Underpricing Your Etsy Shop? 5 Warning Signs

Written by

Store Score Team

in

A shop that’s constantly busy but never seems to have money left over usually isn’t a marketing problem. It’s a pricing problem wearing a marketing costume.

Table of Contents

Introduction

Etsy sellers rarely find out they’re underpricing from a single bad month. It shows up slowly, as a shop that looks busy on the outside (steady orders, decent reviews) while the person running it can’t explain where the money actually went.

These are the five warning signs worth checking in your own numbers, not vague ones like “I feel like I should charge more.” Each one below is something you can verify directly in your own Etsy Shop Manager or bank statement in under ten minutes. Let’s go through them.

1. Your Fees Eat More Than 20% of Revenue

If Etsy’s combined fees are taking more than roughly 20% of what a listing brings in, your price almost certainly hasn’t been set to absorb them.

Etsy’s core, unavoidable fees are structural, not negotiable: a $0.20 listing fee per item, a 6.5% transaction fee on the total amount the buyer pays including shipping, and a payment processing fee that for US sellers runs 3% plus $0.25 per transaction (Fees & Payments Policy – Etsy). On a typical $30 item with $5 shipping, those three fees alone total roughly $3.78, before any Etsy Ads spend or Offsite Ads fee is factored in.

Here’s the deal:

A seller pricing a $15 item with $2 materials cost and no accounting for these fees isn’t actually keeping $13 in profit. They’re keeping closer to $11.50 once the mandatory fees are subtracted, and that’s before their own labor time is counted at all.

Here’s how to check it:

  1. Pull your last 10 sales from Shop Manager’s order history.
  2. Add up the total fees Etsy charged on each (listing, transaction, payment processing).
  3. Divide total fees by total revenue from those 10 orders.

Pro Tip: If that number is consistently above 20%, don’t cut corners on materials to compensate. Build the fee percentage directly into your pricing formula so every sale automatically absorbs it. Our full Etsy pricing calculator guide walks through exactly how.

Fees change over time. Always verify current rates on Etsy’s own Fees & Payments Policy page before finalizing your pricing.

2. You Can’t Answer “What Do I Keep Per Hour?”

If you can’t quickly calculate what you actually earn per hour on your most time-consuming product, that product is very likely underpriced.

This works because handmade pricing hides labor cost more easily than any other input. Material costs are visible and easy to track. Time is invisible unless a seller deliberately tracks it, which means it’s the input most often left out of a price entirely.

Here’s the deal:

A seller who spends three hours hand-stitching an item priced at $35, with $8 in materials and roughly $5 in fees, is left with $22 for three hours of work, about $7.33 an hour, often before accounting for design time, photography, or customer service on top of production.

Here’s how to do it:

  1. Time yourself making one unit of your most popular product, start to finish, including any drying, curing, or packaging time.
  2. Subtract materials and estimated fees from the sale price.
  3. Divide what’s left by the hours spent.

Pro Tip: Do this math for your three best-selling items, not just one. A shop can have one well-priced item propping up two underpriced ones without the seller ever noticing which is which.

3. You’ve Never Raised a Price Since Launch

A price that hasn’t moved since a shop’s first listing almost never reflects current material costs, current demand, or the seller’s now-improved skill and speed.

This works because pricing anchored to launch-day guesswork rarely gets revisited unless something forces the question, and material costs, shipping rates, and Etsy’s own fee structure all shift over time even when a listing’s price doesn’t.

Here’s the deal:

A seller who launched a candle line two years ago at $18, when wax and fragrance oil cost less and technique was still developing, is very likely undercharging today relative to both current input costs and the seller’s now-faster, more consistent production process.

Here’s how to check it:

  1. Pull up your oldest active listing and its original price (visible in your own listing history in Shop Manager).
  2. Compare current material costs for that same item against what they were at launch.
  3. Ask honestly whether your production speed or quality has improved since then, and whether the price reflects that.

Pro Tip: Raising prices doesn’t require a dramatic jump. Our guide on raising Etsy prices without losing sales covers a gradual approach that tests the market instead of guessing blind.

4. Sales Are High But Your Bank Balance Isn’t

A shop with strong order volume and thin or nonexistent take-home profit is one of the clearest underpricing signals there is, because volume is masking margin.

This works because order count is the metric sellers see constantly, right there in Shop Manager’s dashboard, while true margin per order takes deliberate math to see. A shop can look successful by every visible signal while quietly losing money or barely breaking even per sale.

Here’s the deal:

A shop doing 40 sales a month at a $2 profit margin per item is generating $80 in real profit for a full month of production, packaging, customer service, and shipping runs: a volume of orders that looks impressive on the outside while paying close to nothing per hour of actual work.

Here’s how to check it:

  1. Calculate true profit per unit (price minus materials, fees, and packaging) for your top 3 products.
  2. Multiply by your typical monthly order count for each.
  3. Compare that number honestly against the hours spent producing, packaging, and shipping that volume.

Pro Tip: High volume at thin margins isn’t automatically bad (some business models are built on volume), but it should be a deliberate choice with the math checked, not an accident discovered by an empty bank account at the end of the month.

5. You Price by Guessing What “Feels Fair,” Not by Formula

Pricing based on a vague sense of what “feels right” or what a competitor charges, without ever running the actual materials-time-fees math, is the single most common root cause behind every other warning sign on this list.

This works because gut-feel pricing tends to anchor low. Sellers who are new to a craft, or who personally undervalue their own time, consistently guess prices lower than the real cost-plus math would produce, and that low anchor then becomes the shop’s baseline for every future listing.

Here’s the deal:

A first-time seller pricing a knit scarf at $20 because “that seems reasonable for a scarf” is skipping the actual calculation of yarn cost, hours spent, and fee percentage entirely, and that guessed number has no relationship to what the item actually costs to make and sell.

Here’s how to fix it:

  1. Use a real formula: (materials + labor at a real hourly rate + fees) ÷ (1 − desired profit margin).
  2. Run that formula for every product, not just once for the shop as a whole.
  3. Compare the formula’s output against what you’re currently charging, and treat any large gap as a signal, not a coincidence.

Pro Tip: Our complete formula for pricing handmade items walks through this exact calculation with worked examples across different product types.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my Etsy prices are too low?

Check the five signs in this guide: fee percentage above roughly 20% of revenue, an hourly rate that doesn’t reflect real labor value, prices unchanged since launch, high order volume without matching bank balance growth, and pricing set by gut feel instead of a real cost-plus formula.

What percentage of Etsy revenue should go to fees?

Etsy’s core mandatory fees (listing, transaction, payment processing) typically run 11-15% of revenue before any advertising spend, according to current fee breakdowns. If your actual number is running noticeably higher than that, your price likely hasn’t been built to absorb the fees properly.

Is it normal for handmade sellers to underprice at first?

It’s extremely common, particularly for new sellers who haven’t yet tracked their real production time or run the full fee math. It’s common enough to be a pattern worth actively checking against, not evidence of a personal failure.

How much profit margin should an Etsy shop target?

There’s no universal number, since it depends on category, materials cost, and competition, but the starting point is ensuring the formula (materials + labor + fees) is fully subtracted before any profit margin is added on top, not guessed as a round number.

Will raising my prices lose me sales?

Not necessarily, and not automatically. Buyers on Etsy are often shopping for craftsmanship and specificity rather than the absolute lowest price in the category; a moderate, well-tested price increase frequently has a smaller effect on sales volume than sellers fear.

How often should I revisit my pricing?

At minimum, whenever a major material cost shifts, and as a general practice, revisiting pricing roughly once or twice a year even without a specific trigger, since input costs and Etsy’s own fee structure can change over that timeframe.

Does this apply to digital product pricing too?

The core principle (pricing that fully accounts for time and fees, not guesswork) applies to digital products as well, though the labor calculation differs since there’s no per-unit material cost involved.

What’s the fastest of these five signs to check?

The fee-percentage check (#1) is usually fastest, since it only requires pulling recent order history from Shop Manager and doing simple division, with no need to time your own labor first.

Can Store Score tell me if I’m underpricing?

Store Score’s audit reviews a shop’s public pricing signals as part of its four-category framework (SEO, pricing, presentation, reviews), flagging pricing patterns worth a closer look, though the detailed per-product cost math in this guide still needs to be run by the seller directly.

Should every product in my shop use the exact same profit margin?

Not necessarily. Some items may reasonably carry a thinner margin as a lower-cost entry point into a shop while others carry a fatter margin, as long as each individual price is the result of deliberate math rather than default guessing.

The Bottom Line

Underpricing rarely announces itself directly. It shows up as a shop that’s busy but not profitable, and the fastest way to catch it is checking these five concrete signs against your own real numbers rather than trusting a gut feeling either way.

If you want a starting point for checking your own shop’s pricing signals alongside SEO, presentation, and reviews, get a free Store Score audit.

Related Articles

For sellers who want to see how their pricing stacks up against other independent shops, cartcompare’s tool and platform comparisons cover broader e-commerce cost-structure comparisons beyond Etsy alone.

About This Research

Store Score is a free shop-audit tool for Etsy sellers, built by StableCommerce. It scores a shop across four categories (SEO, pricing, presentation, and reviews/social proof) using only publicly visible shop data read through the Etsy Open API, and returns specific, ranked recommendations instead of generic advice.

This guide applies the pricing criteria from that audit framework, cross-checked against Etsy’s own published Fees & Payments Policy.

Content reviewed and updated: 2026-04-29

This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute financial or tax advice. Fees and figures cited are current as of publishing and are always subject to change. Verify current rates on Etsy’s own Fees & Payments Policy page before making pricing decisions. Store Score does not guarantee any specific sales or ranking outcome.

Connect With Us

Want a starting point for checking your own shop’s pricing signals? Try Store Score free and get a ranked list of exactly what to check first.

More posts